All testsAli Demirbaş - Lab
TRGet in touch

Search & Filtering

Making the Navigation Menu Sticky: A/B Test Example

A sticky menu lets visitors navigate without returning to its original position. It also reduces the space available for page content. Keep the menu’s content and size unchanged and compare whether it stays fixed in place.

A/B test scenario. This page is a test plan, not the result of a real experiment.

  • UI elements
  • Purchase conversion rate (CR)

Control vs Variant

What the interface does on its own is the variable.

Changed
Behavior
Page
UI elements
Difference
changed

Hypothesis

If the menu stays fixed at its current edge as visitors scroll, they no longer need to go back to the top to jump to another section of a long page. Easier navigation could then lift purchase conversion, though the gain may vanish if the menu squeezes the content area too much.

Test plan

Calculate sample size

When to run this test

This test makes sense when session recordings show visitors scrolling back up long pages to reach the menu, or heatmaps show menu clicks clustering at page load. Expect visitors to use the menu from mid-page and view more pages per session without exiting more often. If visitors cannot find the section they want in the menu, the problem is its content, not its position, so fix that first. Before launch, check that the menu takes up only a small part of the screen, does not make the page jump when it sticks and does not slow the page with shadows or animations.

How to measure success

Purchase conversion rate (CR)

Compare purchases among eligible visitors assigned to the fixed or standard menu.

Also track

  • Menu click-through rateCompare menu clicks per eligible assigned visitor.
  • Pages per sessionCompare pages viewed during the same session window.
  • Key content visibilityCheck whether the fixed menu covers important page content.
  • Exit rateCompare exits using the same session definition.

How to set it up

  • NavigationCheck whether the fixed menu makes on-page navigation easier.
  • ScrollingSee whether visitors can navigate without returning to the top.
  • MobileReview navigation on long pages, especially on mobile.
  • Screen spaceCheck how much content area the menu occupies.
  • PositionKeep the menu in its current location; testing top versus bottom placement is separate.

What to watch when reading the result

  1. 1Higher menu click-through and more pages per session are not a reason to ship on their own; visitors may be browsing more and buying less. Let purchase conversion make the decision, and check that exit rate does not rise.
  2. 2Read the effect on mobile and desktop separately, since a sticky menu takes a bigger share of a small screen. Use the key content visibility measure to confirm the menu does not cover the CTA or filters on mobile; if it does, do not ship the result as it stands. The finding is limited to the tested pages and the menu's current edge; top versus bottom placement needs its own test.
  3. 3Keep the menu's structure and content the same for the whole test; even one added link blurs whether the gap comes from sticking the menu or from what is in it. If the conversion gap is small, test whether it goes beyond ordinary noise with the A/B test significance calculator; a large swing in menu clicks does not answer that question.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do more menu clicks mean the sticky menu won?

No. Use purchase conversion as the primary outcome. Menu clicks and page views explain navigation changes. Check that exits do not worsen.

What is the main risk of a sticky menu?

It reduces available content space. Check visibility and ensure the mobile menu does not cover CTAs or filters. Avoid excessive height.

What should the implementation avoid?

Prevent layout shifts when the menu sticks. Avoid slow animations or shadows and review navigation on long mobile pages separately.

More tests in Search & Filtering

All tests

Mega Menu or Simple Horizontal Menu A/B Test Example

UI elementsPurchase conversion rate (CR)

Compare a multi-column mega menu with a one-row horizontal menu without a mega panel. The category hierarchy changes too; see both arms and the KPI.

Search & Filtering

Simplifying the Menu Item Set: Navigation A/B Test

UI elementsPurchase conversion rate (CR)

See how a reduced navigation menu is tested against the current full sub-item set, including the removed items, the setup and the measured KPI.

Search & Filtering

Adding a Discount Percentage Filter: A/B Test Idea

FiltersPurchase conversion rate (CR)

This page walks through adding a discount-rate filter to the filter panel: the control panel, the treatment arm, the tested element and the KPI.

Search & Filtering